Applying eye makeup, whether it’s eye shadow or eyeliner, is always a challenge for anyone with oily eyelids. Eyeliner is especially worrisome, though since it ends up almost fading completely or worse, smearing all over your eyes by the end of the day. Although we can’t really stop our face from producing oil since it’s something that comes naturally from our hormones, we can choose the right product to avoid making a mess of our eye makeup.
Topnotch Eyeliner for Oily Lids
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
- It is waterproof and easy to apply
- Doesn’t create smudges
- Best in user experience feedback
Here’s a guide to selecting the best eyeliner for those struggling with oily eyelids and a list of the most noteworthy eyeliner products.
Buying Guide – Tips for choosing eyeliner for oily lids:
- Avoid thick products that can cake on your eyelids. Choose thinner consistency products that you can apply in a thin layer, and then add more as necessary.
- Look for an eyeliner product that offers long-lasting coverage. Anything of lesser quality and not guaranteed long-lasting will tend to gradually slide off your lids.
- The eyeliner should also be waterproof. A waterproof formulation resists rubbing and stays in place, and only makeup removers are able to wipe them away.
- Opt for gel eyeliners over pencil and liquid. Gel eyeliners are best and they’re made especially to provide staying power and vibrant color with just a small amount.
- If you insist on using pencil eyeliners, choose a primer for your eyes first or give your eyes a light coating of powder before putting on the liner to help the liner stick and remain fixed.
- For cream eyeliners, pair them with powder eye shadow in a complementary color to make them last. You can put the powder eye shadow either beneath or on top of your cream eyeliner.
- Select kohl eyeliners that can be applied in just one layer. They also need to be protected underneath by applying some setting powder on your eyelids first.
Eyeliners for oily lids
| || || || ||
|Urban Decay – 24/7 Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner||Applies via super slim brush for more precise line; rich color dries after in 1 minute & lasts the entire day; Its waterproof ability means it does not smudge. This eyeliner is also available in a full range of bright and fantastic colors.||Very Good||Low||4.5 / 5|
|Clinique Brush-On Cream Liner||Waterproof & fragrance-free formula safe for sensitive eyes; thinner texture liner looks good in single layer but can be added for stronger effect; stays on lids without a fuss||Very Good||Mid-Range||4.6 / 5|
|Shu Uemura – Calligraph Ink Liquid Eyeliner Pen||Asian calligraphy-inspired designed applicator pen; comes with easy-to-grasp precise thicker brush with waterproof gorgeous color + all-day staying power; easy to refill||Good||Mid-Range||4.0 / 5|
|Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Eyeliner||Long-lasting wear gel eyeliner formulated to maintain consistency without drying easily from container; easy to apply even for beginners; doesn’t flake or smear||Very Good||Mid-Range||4.2 / 5|
|Lancome – Artliner||Liquid eyeliner pen stays longer with a remarkable sharp tip for precise; glides on skin smoothly; provides intense pigmented colors with just a single layer without smears, fading or running||Very Good||Mid-Range||4.3 / 5|
|MAC Fluidline||Gel-form eyeliner smooth & easy application with matte, long-lasting finish; all-day wear without smudging or fading; intense colors affords single application without layering for coverage||Excellent||Mid-Range||4.8 / 5|
|Benefit – Magic Ink||Liquid eyeliner answers women’s oily skin problem; includes slender brush applicator & easy-to-apply one stroke finish; lovely vivid color sets, dries fast & stays for hours||Good||High||3.9 / 5|
|Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner||Liquid waterproof easy-control product; slim felt point for angling coarse or slender lines; provides impressive staying power & resists smudges.||Very Good||Mid-Range||4.2 / 5|
1. Urban Decay – 24/7 Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
The Urban Decay 24/7 Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner is truly an amazing product for oily skin. The eyeliner’s applicator brush is so slim but sturdy for a more precise line, giving you ultimate control. The rich color dries after about a minute and then it lasts the whole day through. Its waterproof ability means it does not smudge. This eyeliner is also available in a full range of bright and fantastic colors.
2. Clinique Brush-On Cream Liner
If you need an eyeliner for oily, blemish-prone or sensitive skin, then you’ll love the Clinique Brush-On Cream Liner. This waterproof and fragrance-free formula is safe for sensitive eyes. A single layer of this thinner texture liner already looks quite good but you can add more layers if you want a stronger color. It stays on your lids with no problem even if you don’t apply a primer or powder. Once it has set, it resists smudging, flaking and fading.
3. Shu Uemura – Calligraph Ink Liquid Eyeliner Pen
What makes the Shu Uemura Calligraph Ink Liquid Eyeliner Pen unique is the Asian calligraphy-inspired design of the applicator pen. The thicker brush with a precisely pointed tip is easy to grasp in your hand and control for creating either more slender or coarser strokes. This eyeliner’s gorgeous color is also waterproof for all-day staying power. Eco-friendly customers will appreciate as well that this is one of the few eyeliner products that’s actually refillable.
4. Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Eyeliner
A classic favorite among eyeliner lovers is the Bobbi Brown Long Wear Gel Eyeliner. Unlike other gel eyeliners in pots which dry out after several months, this one is formulated to keep its consistency and avoids drying out in the pot. It’s quite easy to apply, even for those who are inexperienced in makeup, plus it stays put for hours and it doesn’t flake or smear. Just make sure to buy the right applicator brush.
5. Lancome – Artliner
The Lancome Artliner is a superb liquid eyeliner pen that stays longer than average liners. It has a remarkably sharp tip for excellent slim strokes and with the right angle, you can easily switch to thicker, bolder streaks. It also glides on to your skin very smoothly. This eyeliner provides beautifully intense pigmented colors that only need a single layer and it’s also free from the threat of smears, fading and running.
6. MAC Fluidline
Another bestseller from MAC is their MAC Fluidline gel eyeliner. Application is smooth and easy and you have a few more seconds before it dries to a matte, long-lasting finish. You can then confidently wear this liner all day without fear of smudges or fading. The intense colors mean a simple single application without need of layering. You’ll need to buy the brush applicator, however, since it doesn’t come with the eyeliner.
7. Benefit – Magic Ink
With its long-lasting ability, Benefit Magic Ink is a liquid eyeliner that’s the perfect answer to the dilemma of many women with oily skin. It includes a slender brush applicator instead of a pen. It’s also easy to apply and takes only one smooth stroke to finish. The vivid color looks absolutely lovely and once it sets and dries, it’s guaranteed to stay for hours. Water and sweat won’t make it budge.
8. Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
A rising star in the makeup industry, Stila Cosmetics has earned the approval of many customers particularly their Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner. This product is easy to control and can be applied easily on the eyelids. The slim felt point can be angled for coarse or slender lines and it creates a color that’s brilliantly dark. It provides impressive staying power as well and resists smudges.